ReplayLaw&Crime Trials

Not guilty
GuiltyFlorida v. Dwain Hall: The Fatal Fetish Murder Trial Defendant: Dwain Hall, 54 Victim: Sonia Exelby, 32, from Portsmouth, England Location: Marion County, Florida Charges: First-degree murder and kidnapping Trial begins: November 16, 2026 Case Summary Dwain Hall is accused of kidnapping, torturing, and murdering 32-year-old British woman Sonia Exelby after the two developed an online relationship through a fetish website. According to investigators, Exelby had struggled with mental health issues and suicidal thoughts. She allegedly connected with Hall, who used the online name "alphasadist," approximately two years before traveling to Florida in October 2025. Authorities believe the two discussed an arrangement in which Hall would torture and ultimately kill her in exchange for approximately $4,000. On October 10, 2025, Hall allegedly picked Exelby up at Gainesville Regional Airport and drove her to a rented Airbnb in Reddick, Florida. Investigators say Hall had purchased rope, a shovel, and other supplies before her arrival. Prosecutors allege that Hall subsequently subjected Exelby to physical and psychological abuse. A disturbing video recovered from his phone reportedly shows Exelby covered in bruises while Hall questions her about wanting to die. However, messages Exelby sent to a friend suggest she had changed her mind. She expressed fear, regret, and a belief that Hall would not allow her to leave. On October 17, investigators discovered Exelby's body buried in a shallow grave in a wooded area of Marion County. An autopsy determined she had died from four stab wounds. Detectives linked Hall to the killing through cellphone location records, financial transactions involving Exelby's bank cards, a shovel containing her DNA, and a knife allegedly mailed to a friend in Ohio that tested positive for her blood. Hall initially denied knowing Exelby before acknowledging their relationship. He has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder and kidnapping. Key Issue at Trial The prosecution's case centers on whether Hall deliberately exploited a vulnerable woman who initially expressed a desire to die but subsequently withdrew her consent and attempted to escape. Even if Exelby originally agreed to the arrangement, consent is not a legal defense to murder in Florida. Hall faces life imprisonment if convicted. Trial Status Jury selection began Monday, November 16, 2026, before Judge Timothy McCourt in Marion County. Opening statements are expected Tuesday, November 17. The trial is anticipated to last approximately one week. Sources: Court TV | WCJB News | FOX 35 Orlando One particularly significant piece of evidence: Prosecutors reportedly recovered messages showing that Exelby was frightened and regretted the arrangement, potentially undermining any suggestion that her death was the result of a continuing consensual agreement.
Added by Trial Empire staff. Shared across broadcasts covering this case.
Courtroom footage may contain disturbing testimony. Allegations are not findings of guilt.
Live4Kaleidoscope of Justice
ArchiveInfamous Sylvia
ArchiveCourtroom community
Live29Trial With Me