TRIAL ARCHIVE · 63 RECORDINGS

Dr. Martin MacNeill

Not guilty

—/100

Guilty

Audience
average—/100Loading…Loading…

Your vote

Not guiltyGuilty

50/100

Loading…

Audience opinion only

One conversation for this archive. During a hosted rewatch, join the host’s playback or choose to watch on your own.

Proceedings · RECORDING 47

2013 trial · Day 12 - Part 1

Martin MacNeill Trial - Day 12 - Part 1

croakerqueen123 · Uploaded 2013-11-06 · Watch on YouTube ↗

Playback availability can change on YouTube. Upload dates are not hearing dates.

← Previous recording Next recording →

CONTENTS OF THE ARCHIVE

The viewing order.

Page 1

Proceedings

2013 trial · Instructions

croakerqueen123

Watch →02

Proceedings

2013 trial · Prosecution Opening Statements

croakerqueen123

Watch →03

Proceedings

2013 trial · Defense Opening Statements

croakerqueen123

Watch →04

Proceedings

2013 trial · Day 1 - Part 1

croakerqueen123

Watch →05

Proceedings

2013 trial · Day 1 - Part 2

croakerqueen123

Watch →06

Proceedings

2013 trial · Day 1 - Part 3

croakerqueen123

Watch →07

Proceedings

2013 trial · Day 2 - Part 1

croakerqueen123

Watch →08

Case background

More background & key dates

The jury found MacNeill guilty of murder and obstruction of justice early on November 9, 2013. This collection follows the 2013 trial through its verdict, including testimony from family members, medical witnesses and others. It does not include his separate sexual-abuse case or a later sentencing hearing.

Compiled by Trial Empire with AI assistance · Sources checked November 11, 2026 · Sources & corrections

Key dates

2007
Michele MacNeill died at the family home in Pleasant Grove. Source ↗
October–November 2013
The murder trial heard medical and other witness testimony. Source ↗
November 9, 2013
The jury convicted Martin MacNeill of murder and obstruction of justice. Source ↗

Collection scope & recording notes

Dr. Martin MacNeill was tried over the 2007 death of his wife, Michele, at their Pleasant Grove, Utah, home. Prosecutors argued that he drugged and drowned her after surgery; the defense disputed the cause of death and the evidence connecting him to a killing. 63 croakerqueen123 uploads: preliminary instructions, both openings, trial Days 1–14 with their source parts and separate motions, jury questions and the verdict. Standalone duplicate 911-call clips and unrelated playlist entries are excluded. No sentencing recording is included. 63 recordings, approximately 70 broadcast hours. Original source titles and credits are retained. LIVE in a title refers to the original broadcast. Recordings can contain breaks and broadcaster commentary; this is not a certified complete court record.

THE VIEWER’S GUIDE · 2013 Utah murder trial

Watch with a question in mind.

Which medical testimony changes how you understand the timeline? Cite the witness, recording and playback time.

Compiled by Trial Empire with AI assistance · Sources & corrections

Find your place.

Watch the openings →
Hear the opening statements, then follow the labeled recording list.
Watch the verdict →
Jump to the verdict recording. This reveals the outcome.
Compare closing arguments →
Hear the defense closing argument; the prosecution closing and rebuttal sit beside it in the recording list.

Before you watch

Does this archive include every MacNeill prosecution?

No. It covers the 2013 murder trial concerning Michele MacNeill, ending with the verdict. The separate sexual-abuse prosecution, sentencing and later proceedings are excluded.

What is included in this collection?

63 croakerqueen123 uploads: preliminary instructions, both openings, trial Days 1–14 with their source parts and separate motions, jury questions and the verdict. Standalone duplicate 911-call clips and unrelated playlist entries are excluded. No sentencing recording is included.

Is this the official complete court record?

No. This is a collection of available recordings. Uploads may contain breaks, commentary, edits or omissions. Original titles and credits are preserved; LIVE refers to the original broadcast. This guide describes the historical proceedings, not current appeal status.

BRING THIS TO THE ROOM

Start with a question.

Which medical testimony changes how you understand the timeline? Cite the witness, recording and playback time.

Join the chat →

Discuss the evidence respectfully. Avoid personal information and unsupported accusations.

Sources & further reading

Recording shortcuts use this collection’s existing source labels. No unverified timestamps or hearing dates have been added.

Dr. Martin MacNeill

Jury Duty

2013 trial · Day 12 - Part 1

The viewing order.

2013 trial · Instructions

2013 trial · Prosecution Opening Statements

2013 trial · Defense Opening Statements

2013 trial · Day 1 - Part 1

2013 trial · Day 1 - Part 2

2013 trial · Day 1 - Part 3

2013 trial · Day 2 - Part 1

2013 trial · Day 2 - Part 2

2013 trial · Day 2 - Part 3

2013 trial · Day 3 - Part 1

2013 trial · Day 3 - Part 2

2013 trial · Day 3 - After Lunch Motions

2013 trial · Day 3 - Part 3

2013 trial · Day 3 - Part 4

2013 trial · Day 4 - Part 1

2013 trial · Day 4 - Objections During Break

2013 trial · Day 4 - Part 2

2013 trial · Day 4 - Part 3

2013 trial · Day 4 - Part 4

2013 trial · Day 5 - Part 1

2013 trial · Day 5 - Part 2

2013 trial · Day 5 - Part 3 (Rachel MacNeill)

2013 trial · Day 5 - Part 4 (Rachel MacNeill)

2013 trial · Day 5 - Part 5 (Rachel MacNeill)

2013 trial · Day 6 - Part 1

2013 trial · Day 6 - Part 2

2013 trial · Day 6 - Part 3

2013 trial · Day 6 - Part 4 (Gypsy Willis)

2013 trial · Day 7 - Part 1 (Gypsy Willis)

2013 trial · Day 7 - Part 2

2013 trial · Day 7 - Part 3 (Ada MacNeill Interview)

2013 trial · Day 8 - Part 1

2013 trial · Day 8 - Part 2 (Alexis Somers)

2013 trial · Day 8 - Part 3 (Alexis Somers)

2013 trial · Day 8 - Part 4 (Alexis Somers)

2013 trial · Day 9 - Part 1

2013 trial · Day 9 - Part 2

2013 trial · Day 9 - Part 3 (Alexis Juror Questions)

2013 trial · Day 9 - Part 4

2013 trial · Day 10 - Part 1

2013 trial · Day 10 - Part 2

2013 trial · Day 10 - Part 3

2013 trial · Day 11 - Part 1

2013 trial · Day 11 - Part 2 (Inmate #3)

2013 trial · Day 11 - Part 3 (Inmate #4)

2013 trial · Day 11 - Part 4 (Inmate #2)

2013 trial · Day 12 - Part 1

2013 trial · Day 12 - Part 2 (Jason Poirier)

2013 trial · Day 12 - Motion for Mistrial

2013 trial · Day 12 - Part 3 (Inmate #1)